Not all industrial activities can rely on a single, universal emission factor. Factors such as fuel type, material characteristics, process technology, energy sources, location, and data quality can all influence the emission factors used in greenhouse gas (GHG) calculations.
Actia provides Emission Factor Calculation Services to assist companies in selecting, calculating, evaluating, and developing emission factors tailored to their specific activity characteristics and calculation requirements.
These services support GHG emission inventories; Scope 1, 2, and 3 calculations; product carbon footprint assessments; decarbonization studies; low-carbon fuel development; and other needs requiring traceable and defensible emission factors.
Emission Factors for Scope 1, Scope 2, and Scope 3
Emission factors are not limited to a single Scope.
Emission factors (EFs) are required across different parts of a company’s greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions inventory. The appropriate emission factors and calculation methodologies should be selected based on the characteristics of each emission source.
Scope 1
Scope 1 covers direct GHG emissions from sources owned or controlled by a company.
Examples include:
- Fuel combustion in boilers;
- Furnaces;
- Generators;
- Company-operated vehicles;
- Industrial processes;
- Fugitive emissions;
- Other direct emission sources.
For these activities, companies can use activity data, such as fuel consumption in liters, gas volume, material quantities, or process parameters, and multiply them by the appropriate emission factors to calculate GHG emissions.
Scope 2
Scope 2 covers indirect emissions from purchased or acquired energy, including electricity, steam, heating, and cooling.
For electricity-related emissions, selecting the appropriate emission factor requires consideration of grid characteristics, geographical location, reporting period, and the calculation methodology applied.
The GHG Protocol also emphasizes the importance of using representative electricity emission factors, including supplier-specific or regional grid emission factors when relevant data is available.
Scope 3
Scope 3 covers other indirect emissions occurring throughout a company’s value chain.
Emission factors may be required to calculate emissions associated with:
- Purchased goods and services;
- Capital goods;
- Upstream transportation and distribution;
- Business travel;
- Employee commuting;
- Waste generated in operations;
- Use of sold products;
- End-of-life treatment of sold products;
- Other Scope 3 categories.
For Scope 3 emissions, the appropriate emission factors may differ from those used for Scope 1 and Scope 2 calculations.
For example, the GHG Protocol distinguishes between combustion emission factors and life cycle emission factors. It also provides guidance on selecting suitable factors based on specific activities and Scope 3 categories.
Sources of Emission Factors for GHG Calculations
Emission factors can be obtained from various sources.
Several commonly used sources for greenhouse gas emissions inventories include:
IPCC
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) provides internationally recognized guidelines and default emission factors widely used in greenhouse gas emissions inventories.
GHG Protocol
The GHG Protocol provides calculation methodologies, tools, and emission factor references for various corporate GHG accounting activities.
Default emission factors can be used when company-specific values are unavailable. However, more specific emission factors are generally preferred when they are available, reliable, and appropriate for the emission source.
Government and Sector-Specific Sources
For projects conducted in Indonesia, emission factors published by government ministries, regulatory agencies, or sector-specific institutions can serve as important references when they are relevant to the activities being assessed.
International Emission Factor Databases
International sources such as the EPA, DEFRA, IEA, EIA, ecoinvent, and other recognized databases may be used depending on the objectives, geographical coverage, data characteristics, and underlying calculation methodologies.
However, the most widely recognized emission factor database is not necessarily the most appropriate source for every project.
Emission factors should always be evaluated based on their intended application and the specific conditions of the emissions inventory.
Are Emission Factors the Same for Every Company?
Not necessarily.
Two companies using the same type of fuel may still require different approaches to emission factor selection and GHG emissions calculations.
Differences may arise from:
- Fuel characteristics;
- Material quality;
- Process technology;
- Geographical location;
- GHG inventory reporting year;
- Activity data;
- System boundaries;
- Calculation objectives;
- Applied methodologies.
The GHG Protocol also recognizes the benefits of using company-specific emission factors when possible, as industrial processes and fuel compositions may vary across geographical regions and over time.
Therefore, selecting an emission factor involves more than simply finding a numerical value in a database and entering it into a spreadsheet.
A proper evaluation is necessary to ensure that the selected emission factor accurately represents the emission source and is suitable for the intended calculation.
Understanding Tier 1, Tier 2, and Tier 3 Emission Factors
The terms Tier 1, Tier 2, and Tier 3 are commonly used in greenhouse gas emissions inventory methodologies.
In general, these tiers represent different levels of methodological detail, data specificity, and calculation complexity.
However, emission factor tiers are not the same as emission Scopes, nor do they refer to specific emission factor databases.
Scope identifies the source and accounting classification of emissions, while Tier describes the methodological approach and level of detail used to estimate emissions.
Therefore, Scope 1 does not automatically correspond to Tier 1, and Scope 2 does not automatically correspond to Tier 2.
The appropriate Tier should be selected based on the characteristics of the emission source, data availability, applicable methodologies, and the objectives of the GHG emissions inventory.
When Do Companies Need Emission Factor Development?
Not every company needs to develop its own emission factors.
Emission factor development becomes relevant when existing emission factors do not adequately represent actual operating conditions or when a company requires more specific factors for particular activities, fuels, materials, or industrial processes.
Examples include:
Low-Carbon Fuels or Alternative Fuels
A company uses fuels with characteristics that are not adequately represented by existing default emission factors.
Specific Fuel Characteristics
The composition or physicochemical properties of a fuel differ from the assumptions underlying available default emission factors.
Specific Industrial Processes
An industrial activity or production technology has unique characteristics that cannot be accurately represented using general emission factors.
Product-Specific Emission Factors
A company requires more specific emission factors for particular materials or products to support emissions calculations, product carbon footprint assessments, or other environmental evaluations.
Improving GHG Inventory Quality
A company aims to reduce uncertainty and improve the accuracy and representativeness of its greenhouse gas emissions inventory.
ACTIA’s Experience in Emission Factor Development
ACTIA has experience in Low-Carbon Fuel Emission Factor Studies, including projects involving reference assessments, physicochemical fuel characterization, and emission factor formulation.
This experience includes approaches based on literature reviews, data analysis, laboratory testing of fuel characteristics, and the development of emission factors tailored to specific study requirements.
Through these activities, ACTIA has developed relevant technical experience in evaluating emission factor applicability and supporting the formulation of more representative emission factors.
This experience provides a foundation for ACTIA to assist companies with emission factor development needs that require more specific technical approaches than simply applying default emission factors.